- Elizabeth Larson
- Posted On
Judge sentences Clearlake man for 2014 killing
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44d3a/44d3ab69611b423b2ec8a20513c888dadc64d106" alt=""
LAKEPORT, Calif. – On Monday a judge sentenced a Clearlake man to state prison for the 2014 killing of a man that investigators concluded was motivated by illegal marijuana growing.
Judge J. David Markham sentenced Gary Joseph Williams, 34, of Clearlake to 16 years in prison for voluntary manslaughter with a gun in the death of Guillermo Figueroa.
The sentence was the result of a plea agreement reached between Williams and his attorney, Patrick Pekin of Fort Bragg, and the California Attorney General’s Office in March, days before Williams’ trial was set to begin, as Lake County News has reported.
The Attorney General’s Office took over prosecution of the case early on due to then-District Attorney Don Anderson’s daughter, Robyn Anderson, her husband Michael Campbell and her daughter, Courtney Crusse, all being named as potential witnesses in court documents.
Crusse, in particular, was a key witness who was granted immunity in the case. Court documents indicated Crusse witnessed Williams fatally shooting Figueroa.
The 36-year-old Figueroa, who lived in Hidden Valley Lake, was reported missing in late October 2014 by his wife after he failed to return from visiting a friend in Clearlake.
In late November 2014, a month after Figueroa’s disappearance, a man living on Oleander Street in Clearlake reported finding a human skull in his yard, which he believed his dog may have found and brought there.
The following day, a search of the area yielded the discovery of partial human remains about 100 yards north of the residence where the skull had been located. An autopsy and DNA analysis confirmed the remains were those of Figueroa.
Figueroa had been involved in illegally growing marijuana, a conclusion investigators based on interviews with numerous witnesses and other subjects.
Williams was arrested on Nov. 26, 2014, on charges relating to a trailer theft. In May 2015, Williams and his girlfriend, Crystal Pearls, were arrested in connection to Figueroa’s murder.
Court records show that Pearls was charged with being an accessory in July 2015 and reached a nolo plea that yielded a three-year sentence in November 2015.
Pekin told Lake County News that the case originally was being considered for the death penalty because it involved a murder during the course of a robbery, one of the special circumstances that qualifies as a capital offense. However, early on the prosecution decided not to pursue the death penalty.
The case was ready to go to trial in March, with a lengthy list of witnesses and many pieces of evidence, when Pekin and the Attorney General’s Office reached the plea agreement.
The Lake County Probation Department did its usual report for the sentencing, which followed the plea agreement terms, and Judge Markham accepted it, giving Williams the 16-year sentence.
As part of the sentencing, Markham was asked to reserve restitution for the Lake County Sheriff’s Office, which had incurred thousands of dollars in expenses with a mortuary for long term storage of Figueroa’s remains.
Markham also approved a request to reserve $3,000 in restitution for Alma Figueroa, Guillermo Figueroa’s wife, who had been turned down by the California Victim Compensation Board because her husband had been involved in illegal marijuana.
During the sentencing, Markham noted that Williams will receive credit for the time he’s already served and, once released, will have to serve up to three years on parole.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.