LAKE COUNTY, Calif. — The Board of Supervisors discussed major changes to the Lucerne Area Town Hall last week, a proposal the district supervisor said is meant to increase inclusivity but one he hasn’t taken to the community directly.
By the end of the discussion last Tuesday, Supervisor EJ Crandell and his supporters seemed to have convinced the board to move forward on the proposal after not clearly explaining who initiated the idea or, precisely, why, other than vague assertions of “inclusivity.”
Crandell hasn’t convened a meeting of the Lucerne Area Town Hall, or LATH, since late in 2022 to discuss any of the proposed changes.
He also made clear that he does not intend to bring the discussion to the community directly, that he would base his decision on the discussion with his fellow board members and community members who spoke at last Tuesday’s meeting.
Crandell’s proposal is to change the name of the group from the Lucerne Area Town Hall to the Central Region Town Hall, or CeRTH.
Under his proposal, it will no longer follow the community growth boundaries — which have been used as the delineation of the town hall’s area since the town hall was established in 2017 — but will now include the entire 95458 ZIP code, which also will include Paradise Valley, a wealthy enclave several miles to the east of the town that recently disconnected from the East Region Town Hall due to lack of involvement.
Crandell gave a brief explanation of the town hall’s formation by then-Supervisor Jim Steele, his mentor who he called “emeritus,” a title typically used in academia which the county doesn’t confer upon former supervisors. Deputy County Administrative Officer Matthew Rothstein told Lake County News that Crandell meant it as a term of respect.
Originally, the town hall had been called the “Middle Region Town Hall” before being changed to the Lucerne Area Town Hall in 2018.
When Board Chair Jessica Pyska asked if he had heard from constituents regarding the proposal, Crandell interjected to say “numerous.” Pyska asked if they had no representation with the town hall, Crandell replied, “Well, yeah,” and said those individuals want to be included.
Crandell claimed that his actions had nothing to do with the fact that LATH had defied him in holding a December meeting — which he had tried to cancel — and
voted unanimously to approve a resolution to oppose a proposal by the Scotts Valley Pomo tribe to turn the historic Lucerne Hotel into a homeless housing facility, a project for which Crandell’s wife has publicly advocated.
In January, Crandell also took the unusual step of hosting a community information session about the hotel project, pulling in the proponents and county staff to explain it without an application being made.
While Crandell denies a link between the issues with LATH’s pushback on the hotel, the timing suggests otherwise, as in the weeks that followed Crandell made clear he was not going to allow further appointments to LATH, other than a reappointment of longtime member Kevin Waycik on Jan. 10. Waycik died in February following a short battle with cancer.
Since January, Crandell has not been forthcoming with his reasons for not making new appointments until the meeting last Tuesday.
Raising concerns about the plan during public comment were John Jensen, co-founder of Lake County News and the Lucerne Area Revitalization Association, and Kurt McKelvey, who has been LATH’s most recent chair.
Jensen suggested that Crandell has a conflict of interest in the matter, as his restructuring proposal has followed the town hall’s rejection of the Lucerne Hotel project. That led Jensen to suggest that the new county counsel should advise Crandell to recuse himself.
Crandell, in response to Jensen, said there is no conflict of interest on his part.
Melanie Lim, who was appointed to LATH last year, said she also was surprised that the meetings had stopped at the end of 2022 and that a Facebook page for the group, where she got her minutes for the meetings, was suddenly erased.
“Nobody told me what happened,” she said, explaining she’s served on a board before and was never treated like this. “I feel like there’s a little bit of drama and I don't want any part of that.”
There were two Facebook pages for the group, one of which still exists. The other is reported to have been managed by Crandell. Lake County News has submitted a request for information to the county regarding that page and the reasons for its disappearance.
Lim said she appreciates inclusiveness and doesn’t want to be left in the dark. “I would like an explanation if there is one.”
Crandell said he had previously given her an explanation about the length of her term, which Lim said she did not remember.
Supervisor Michael Green then tried to call a point of order to say they were well off the agenda item and Pyska responded by telling him she was running the meeting.
Several Upper Lake residents as well as Olga Martin Steele, wife of Crandell’s predecessor as well as Crandell’s original campaign manager who lives in Clearlake Oaks, spoke in favor of the plan.
Due to some of the speakers who followed Jensen and McKelvey aiming their comments at members of the public, Supervisor Bruno Sabatier said the comments should be directed to the board, asking them to please stick to the item.
Pyska asked Crandell for a timeline of when the next actions would take place.
Crandell indicated it would be two to three weeks.
Then, he read a letter from Lani Kane Urquiza, a former LATH chair, who accused Jensen and McKelvey of undermining LATH and efforts to update the bylaws and criticized Lake County News’ coverage of the town hall.
A few minutes after reading the message, Crandell claimed that those were not his words.
Urquiza’s issues with Lake County News likely arise from the fact that the publication made formal complaints to her — and about her — to Crandell and to then-County Counsel Anita Grant during her tenure as chair regarding Urquiza’s persistent failure to follow the Brown Act in calling and holding LATH meetings.
Those failures included not posting the meeting agendas in a timely manner under the law — both online and in physical locations around the town — along with failure to distribute the agendas to those who asked for them and attempts to hold meetings that had failed to be properly noticed.
In at least one instance, LATH’s Brown Act issues while Urquiza was chair resulted in Grant coming to hold a Brown Act workshop with the group.
At no point did Crandell — or, for that matter, the county’s other leadership — in the past indicate a willingness to hold Urquiza accountable. When issues were raised about her behavior, the county did not respond. Nor did Crandell disclose the fact that she was a family friend, which appeared to be the likeliest reason why she was appointed by him as a council member and made chair shortly thereafter.
Like Urquiza, Crandell also mentioned bylaws the group had been working on beginning in 2019, which he called a “template.”
Regarding the “template” bylaws that both Crandell and Urquiza spoke of last Tuesday, that “template” contained a provision that would have allowed nonresident property owners to be voting members of the board.
Crandell didn’t further explain the origins of that “template.” However, that provision was championed by Urquiza on behalf of her then-employer, Kenny Parlet, owner of Lakeview Market in Lucerne.
Parlet, despite being a member of the Lakeport City Council — during the meetings for which he has increasingly begun to make statements about his fears related to COVID-19 vaccinations and chemtrails — had told the LATH on various occasions that he deserved to also have a seat on LATH.
He claimed to be the community’s largest taxpayer, although that does not appear to be the case when looking at the higher assessed value of other commercial properties in Lucerne such as PowerMart, which has a gas station and market.
Ultimately, however, those bylaws changes were rejected and a version without that provision allowing out-of-town residents a seat on the board was approved both by LATH and then, on Oct. 18, by the Board of Supervisors itself in a unanimous vote that included Crandell.
In his role as LATH chair, McKelvey led the effort to bring attention to the Lucerne Hotel plan and also raised issues with the operations of Elijah House, a nonprofit organization that the county had failed to vet before giving it hundreds of thousands of dollars to run the county’s homeless shelter.
Had the county — specifically the Behavioral Health Services Department — vetted the organization, it would have found that it was out of compliance with California Attorney General’s Office nonprofit filing requirements.
Elijah House stopped operating the shelter over the summer and a few months later pulled out of operating a sober living environment in Lucerne’s former visitor center after Lake County News pressed the county, in public, on why that facility was being allowed to operate within a commercial zone.
The county also is supposedly conducting an investigation into Elijah House, the result of which still hasn't been made public. In the meantime, the supervisors bid a fond farewell to Behavioral Health Services Director Todd Metcalf earlier this month, who is headed to Hawaii, without having to respond publicly to the outcome of the Elijah House investigation.
McKelvey pressed Crandell on whether new appointments to LATH would be made ahead of a change to the group. Crandell said the changes were happening first.
In response, McKelvey said LATH should have a part in the discussion, and that it wasn’t appropriate to make that decision before the appointments.
“Noted, thank you,” Crandell said.
Board members indicated support for Crandell’s plan.
Crandell’s stalling of town hall meetings also has prevented the community from receiving updates from Northshore Fire Protection District Chief Mike Ciancio.
In a special district board meeting to discuss staffing last week, Ciancio said he’s continued to make his rounds to other town halls over the last several months, noting he’s done the fewest update in Lucerne, where he’s waiting for the town hall’s issues “to get straightened out.”
Following last week’s Board of Supervisors meeting, Lake County News submitted a Public Records Act to the county, requesting to obtain records of communications between Crandell and the community members he said have contacted him, leading to the proposed changes to the town hall.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.