LAKE COUNTY, Calif. – A man with a lengthy and violent criminal history – including a 1997 killing – has been sentenced to 27 years in prison for kidnapping and threatening a woman in late 2012 because he believed she had stolen marijuana from his nephew.
Charles Vasil Statler, 54, of Santa Rosa received the sentence on Monday from Judge Andrew Blum.
On April 17 – at the end of a trial that began about three weeks earlier – a jury convicted Statler of felony kidnapping, carjacking, vehicle theft, criminal threats, and having previous strikes and prison terms after only an hour and a half of deliberations, according to Chief Deputy District Attorney Richard Hinchcliff, who prosecuted Statler's case.
Statler’s defense attorney, Mitch Hauptman, declined comment on the case or its outcome.
Statler and two Clearlake Oaks men – James Daniel Austin and Ricky Lane McCullough – were arrested in January 2013 for the kidnapping of a 49-year-old woman the previous month, as Lake County News has reported.
Court documents show that the female victim reported to deputies that the three men used a pickup to block her vehicle as she was driving on Second Street in Upper Lake on the afternoon of Dec. 4, 2012. Statler pulled the woman from her vehicle and forcing her into the pickup, then took her car, with both vehicles leaving the scene.
For the next six to seven hours, she was driven to several locations around Lake County – including a remote area in Upper Lake where Statler was involved in a large marijuana growing operation – and showed a hole that she was told she would be put into if she didn't provide the information the men wanted, case documents explained.
She also had her fingers placed in a pair of pliers, and was threatened that she would have her fingers cut off. Statler and the two other men also drove the victim to other areas of the county, threatening to gang rape her, according to the investigation.
Statler, Austin and McCullough accused the woman – who acknowledged to law enforcement that she was working as a marijuana trimmer – of stealing 140 pounds of marijuana – valued at about $150,000 – from a third man, Robert Whitmire of Petaluma, Statler's nephew.
“There was never any evidence whatsoever that was the case,” said Hinchcliff of the marijuana theft allegations.
Later that night, the men took the victim back to her home and took a large amount of cash from her, based on the investigative reports.
In February McCullough pleaded no contest to false imprisonment and admitted a prior prison term, and was sentenced to four years in the county jail, case documents indicated.
In May, Austin pleaded to a charge of being an accessory to a felony, and was sentenced to 365 days in the county jail and three years' formal probation, according to court records.
Statler's criminal history includes an assault in Oregon; theft cases in Arizona, California and Texas; and the killing of 68-year-old retiree Raymond Churchill in Lake County in October 1997.
Case records showed Statler – who lived with Churchill in a trailer on Spruce Grove Road in Lower Lake – killed Churchill by hitting him in the head multiple times with a steel skillet. He hit Churchill so hard that it fractured his skull, broke his spine and severed the skillet handle.
Statler claimed he killed Churchill in self-defense during a drunken argument. However, prosecutors suggested his actions after the killing showed intent.
According to the investigation, Statler had dumped Churchill's body in the Jerusalem Valley area near Middletown, concealing it in a manzanita thicket.
Statler then went about destroying evidence, including washing his own clothes, burning Churchill's clothing, and dismantling, burning and burying Churchill's Volkswagen station wagon.
Statler also took Churchill's ring and wore it, and used Churchill's ATM card to withdraw $591 from his account the day after the killing.
Then-District Attorney Gary Luck prosecuted Statler for Churchill's killing, winning a conviction for second-degree murder, grand theft and fraudulently using an access card in the case. In March 1999 Statler was sentenced to 18 years and eight months to life in state prison, according to case documents.
However, in 2005 an appeals court overturned Statler's murder conviction, and sent it back to Lake County for retrial. Luck offered Statler a plea agreement for voluntary manslaughter, which Statler accepted the following year.
Statler ended up getting a 13-year sentence for voluntary manslaughter. Records show he was paroled in the Churchill killing in August 2009.
The Monday sentencing is likely to keep Statler in prison for the remainder of his life.
Hinchcliff said Statler received 27 years and eight months, and due to the crimes' violent nature he must serve 85 percent of that term. He also was fined $8,960.
Correction: The original story said that the appeal court reduced Statler’s second-degree murder sentence. The court actually sent the case back for retrial. That is reflected in the corrected story above.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. . Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.