- Elizabeth Larson
- Posted On
Judge denies bail to woman charged with killing boyfriend
Tammy Sue Grogan-Robinson, 56, made an in-person appearance in Lake County Superior Court before Judge J. David Markham on Tuesday afternoon.
She is accused of the killing of her on-again, off-again boyfriend, 56-year-old Charles Vernon McClelland of Rohnert Park, whose body was found by deputies on the morning of July 7 in the Clearlake Oaks residence where she was living.
Authorities said Grogan-Robinson shot McClelland several times with a handgun.
Grogan-Robinson later left the state for Missouri, where she has family. She was arrested in Missouri in mid-August, less than a week after the District Attorney’s Office charged her with McClelland’s murder.
In an appearance last week via Zoom, Grogan-Robinson told Judge Markham she wanted to hire an attorney after previously having said she wanted to represent herself, as Lake County News has reported.
On Tuesday, attorney Mitch Hauptman, who has made special appearances to act as her defense attorney, asked Markham to lower Grogan-Robinson’s bail from $2 million to an amount she could afford.
Hauptman told the court that Dr. Chris Lombardo, a surgeon who has worked with Grogan-Robinson at a local hospital — she’s a surgical tech — was vouching for her character and willing to provide her with housing should she be released on lowered bail.
During the brief hearing, Hauptman put Grogan-Robinson on the stand for a few minutes to ask her about her assets to determine if she could afford to hire her own attorney. He concluded she had the ability to post bail as high as $75,000 to $100,000 based on a small 401(k) and limited cash she had on hand.
He emphasized that she had no previous criminal record.
Deputy District Attorney Rich Watson argued that Grogan-Robinson should be held without bail, telling the court McClelland’s murder was premeditated.
Watson said that at 8:40 p.m. the night before the murder, Grogan-Robinson texted a friend to say she was going to shoot McClelland in the face. Ten minutes later, she wrote to ask the friend to erase the texts.
Two hours after that, Grogan-Robinson sent another text saying she was going to shoot McClelland because of the way he treated her, Watson said.
Watson argued that Grogan-Robinson was both a flight risk — citing her going to Missouri — and a substantial risk to the community. Even if she was released with an ankle monitor, he said it wouldn’t stop her from going into a jealous rage and harming someone.
In reply, Hauptman said he had a text about a return flight to Lake County that Grogan-Robinson had planned, and which was scheduled for the day after she ended up being arrested.
He said she was planning to return to Lake County but had simply gone to Missouri to be with her family, as she was freaked out because it was her perception that she was the victim of a rape.
Early on in the investigation, Grogan-Robinson told authorities she had killed McClelland after a sexual assault, but sheriff’s detectives later concluded the shooting had not been justified.
In reviewing the case, Markham said he believed Grogan-Robinson had committed the murder and that she had planned it.
“She told people she was going to do it. She did it and then she left the area afterwards,” Markham said.
Markham said he found there is clear and convincing evidence that no conditions of release can protect the public or ensure Grogan-Robinson’s attendance at her trial.
He then ordered her to be held without bail.
Markham set Grogan-Robinson’s next court appearance for 11 a.m. Oct. 13 in his courtroom, at which time her hired attorney is to make a first appearance and she will enter her plea to the charges.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.