A preliminary hearing began on Wednesday, September 28, 2011, for (from left) Paul Braden, Orlando Lopez and Kevin Stone, who are accused of taking part part in a shooting in Clearlake, Calif., on Saturday, June 18, 2011, that left a 4-year-old boy dead and five others wounded. Lake County Jail photos.
CLEARLAKE, Calif. – The events that culminated in a June shooting that left a child dead and several people wounded were explored in the first day of a preliminary hearing for three local men that got under way on Wednesday.
Orlando Joseph Lopez, 23, and Paul William Braden, 21, of Clearlake Oaks and Kevin Ray Stone, 29, of Clearlake sat in the jury box throughout the first day of their preliminary hearing, set to continue for several more days.
The three men are facing charges of murder, mayhem, and numerous counts of attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon, along with special allegations for use of firearms and great bodily injury for a late night shooting on June 18 that killed 4-year-old Skyler Rapp and wounded the child's mother, Desiree Kirby; her boyfriend, Ross Sparks, and his brother, Andrew Sparks; and friends Ian Griffith and Joseph Armijo.
Security in the courtroom was heightened on Wednesday. In addition to two correctional officers and the bailiff, a sheriff's sergeant and two deputies oversaw the proceedings as about a dozen friends and family members of the victims filtered in and out to watch the testimony.
During a brief meeting in Judge Stephen Hedstrom's chambers before the hearing started, District Attorney Don Anderson and defense attorneys Stephen Carter, Doug Rhoades and Komnith Moth – representing Lopez, Braden and Stone, respectively – settled on an estimate of five days of preliminary hearing, Hedstrom said afterward.
A total of 21 witnesses will take the stand in the coming days, Hedstrom said once court convened.
In the first day of testimony, cousins Joshua Gamble and Ross Sparks were called to the stand, both of them describing tensions, threats and fights with members of a local gang which are believed to have contributed to the June 18 shooting, the worst in the city's history, according to police.
The bulk of the day's testimony came from 17-year-old Gamble, a Lower Lake High School student who often spent time at the home Ross Sparks and Kirby shared at 14034 Lakeshore Drive, where the shooting took place.
In more than three hours of testimony and cross-examination, Gamble described not just the night of the shooting but a fight that occurred when he and Armijo attended a friend's adult school graduation event at Lower Lake High School. The Konocti Unified School District calendar shows that the event took place on Thursday, June 9.
Gamble said he was taunted by a group called the “Ave. Boys,” named for the city's Avenues area, where the teens live.
“They made up their own gang or whatever” about a year ago, said Gamble, testifying during the day that the teens had had the name shaved into their hair at one point.
Wearing white shirts, red caps and blue jeans, the group followed Gamble and Armijo out of the graduation and attacked them. Lopez's brother, Leonardo, allegedly came up during the fight and hit Gamble in the head with a pipe.
Gamble said he was acquainted with Leonardo Lopez – who had dated his sister about three years previously – but said he didn't know him personally.
When cross-examined by Carter about his history with the Ave. Boys, Gamble said that he had a developmentally delayed cousin named Johnny who a member of the gang beat up about two years ago. Armijo was beaten up by the gang members the year before that, Gamble added.
On June 18 Gamble went over to hang out and play video games at Sparks' home, later walking down to Austin Park and heading back to the Lakeshore Drive home at around 6 p.m.
At the home that evening Ross Sparks and Desiree Kirby received a total of three threatening phone calls that upset them, said Gamble. At least one of the calls was attributed to Leonardo Lopez.
Over the course of the evening on June 18 about a dozen other people – including Sparks, Kirby and their two young children – were gathered at the home, where they had a barbecue. Gamble's sister, Amanda, roasted marshmallows to make Skyler s'mores.
Sparks' neighbor, Curtis Eeds, came over briefly to talk to him. A man nicknamed “Goofy,” who came from Eeds' home and who Gamble had never seen before, came and stood up against the fence for most of the evening. Gamble said he had wondered why the man stood off by himself.
During questioning, Anderson had Gamble draw the locations of the party's participants on a map of the homes. Gamble also described the fence – located between the apartments where the couple and their children lived and the home of Curtis Eeds – which had a large hole in it where boards were missing.
It was over and through that fence that several gunshots were fired that wounded the couple and their friends, and killed Skyler Rapp, according to Wednesday's testimony.
When he first heard the gunshots, Gamble said he thought it was a firecracker. “I heard a loud pop, like 'Pow!' Then I heard another one. And then I noticed what it really was,” he said.
Shortly afterward, everyone scattered, Gamble said.
Anderson asked him if he saw Skyler. Gamble said yes.
“Did you see Skyler fall?” Anderson asked.
“Yes,” said Gamble, choking up.
He said the child collapsed within seconds of the start of the shooting. One of the women at the home went to him and cradled him as he lay on the ground.
Gamble testified to hearing at least four gunshots, and seeing five muzzle blasts, the first from over the fence, the second from the area where the hole in the fence was located.
“It felt like hours but it was only minutes,” he said of the shooting.
A shrine set up for 4-year-old Skyler Rapp at a memorial for him in Clearlake, Calif., on June 22, 2011. Photo by Elizabeth Larson.
Exploring connections
Gamble said he saw a tall “lanky” figure – whose head and shoulders were visible – firing a handgun over the top of the fence with their right hand. The handgun's report sounded like “pap, pap, pap,” while the firearm shot through the fence had a lower, louder boom.
The only lighting came from porch lights – one in a neighbor's yard and the one from Sparks' home. Gamble said he could only see shadowy figures shooting at him and his friends.
He couldn't discern the subjects' skin tone or ethnicity, although he said the subject shooting over the fence – who may have been standing or sitting on a washing machine in the yard – had short hair.
“When the shots first started I was like a deer caught in the headlights. I didn't know what to do,” said Gamble.
One of the suspects then stepped through the hole in the fence, and Gamble said he believed at that point that the shooters were coming to get the group.
Gamble ran between a car parked nearby and the apartments, then jumped a side fence and ran down the street. He said he stopped about a block away in someone's yard when the gunshots stopped. He then ran back.
When he got back to the apartment, he found a horrible scene.
“My cousin Andrew was walking around with holes all through his legs and his arm,” said Gamble.
Kirby was lying in the doorway, and Armijo and Griffith were lying on the floor in the front room. Gamble said Ross Sparks was running around outside, saying his son had been shot, while bearing a gunshot wound near his hip.
“It was just a clean hole, straight through,” Gamble said of Sparks' wound.
During cross-examination, Moth pressed Gamble on whether he had been drinking beer that day with the others at the barbecue. He said no. Moth would also question Gamble closely about his use of marijuana that day, and whether or not it impaired him. Gamble said no.
Carter questioned Gamble closely about Eeds and “Goofy,” and their actions on the night of the shooting.
Gamble couldn't remember where Goofy – who had stood near the fence and away from the group during that night – was when the shooting started.
“You can't rule them out as the shooters, can you?” Carter asked of Eeds and Goofy, with Gamble saying he didn't know.
Carter also asked Gamble about statements to police on the night of the shooting, in which he stated he didn't think the fight at the graduation event and the shooting were related.
Gamble clarified that he stated to police, “I told them I didn't know.”
When Sparks took the stand at the end of the day, he told the court that he considered Skyler his child.
He said he knew Orlando Lopez, who had played football with Sparks' younger brother. Sparks also knew Braden, whose brother was a good friend of his in high school. Sparks said he also worked for Braden's father.
Sparks said he did not know Stone.
In the days before the shooting, Sparks said he spoke with Orlando Lopez at Eeds' home, where Sparks said he was doing laundry.
Sparks said he and Lopez had a discussion about Gamble's run-in with Leonardo Lopez and his friends at the high school.
He said Orlando Lopez told him not to worry about it, that he would handle it. “He was totally cool like he was my friend,” Sparks said.
Sparks said Lopez was at Eeds' home with a man named “Boxer,” who claimed that the Ave. Boys were his clique and “they get sh**” done.
“You will see,” Boxer told Sparks.
Days later Sparks said he received a text message, purportedly from Lopez, that said, “F*** your life.”
When the preliminary continues on Thursday – with additional testimony expected from Sparks – the attorneys and Hedstrom will discuss whether that text message is admissible or if it must be excluded due to hearsay evidence rules, an issue they went over at the end of Wednesday's proceedings.
The issue of the text message and whether it could be considered actually interrupted Sparks' testimony and resulted in Hedstrom asking him to step down from the stand and wait outside of the courtroom.
Hedstrom called it “a very important issue in this case.”
E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. . Follow Lake County News on Twitter at http://twitter.com/LakeCoNews, on Tumblr at www.lakeconews.tumblr.com, on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/pages/Lake-County-News/143156775604?ref=mf and on YouTube at http://www.youtube.com/user/LakeCoNews .