- Elizabeth Larson
- Posted On
Suspects in Clearlake murder arraigned; bail for alleged shooter set at $2.9 million
LAKEPORT, Calif. – The alleged shooter in a Sunday homicide in Clearlake and his three co-defendants made their first court appearances in the case on Tuesday afternoon.
Clearlake residents Joshua Robert Beavers, 24; Orlando Esquivel Sr., 48; Angel Aileen Esquivel, 50; and Brenden Alicea, 26, appeared in Judge Richard Martin's court on Tuesday afternoon.
The four are facing charges in connection to the Sunday afternoon triple shooting that left 29-year-old David Ferrell dead.
Beavers is alleged to have used a .22-caliber handgun to fatally shoot Ferrell and to wound Rachel Patterson, 25, and Paul Cressy, 52, during a confrontation at a residence at 19th and Gardner avenues, according to the prosecution.
Patterson, grazed on the side by a bullet, was taken to St. Helena Hospital Clear Lake on Sunday and released a short time later. An air ambulance took Cressy to Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital for treatment of a wound to his elbow, police said.
Police said the shooting followed a fight that took place earlier on Sunday between one of the suspects and one of the shooting victims.
All four suspects were detained at a residence on 21st Avenue in Clearlake within hours of the shooting police said.
Late Sunday night police found the handgun they believe was used in the shooting, along with a .410 shotgun with a pistol grip that also was present at the incident but not used, in some bushes in the area of 16th and Boyles avenues.
The District Attorney's Office has filed 11 counts and numerous special allegations against Beavers, including murder, attempted murder, assault with a firearm, discharging a firearm in a grossly negligent manner, assault with a semiautomatic firearm and carrying a loaded handgun in a vehicle or public place.
Beavers, who has previous felony convictions in Sonoma County in 2008 – participation in a criminal street gang and vandalism – also is facing charges for being a felon in possession of a firearm and ammunition.
At Chief Deputy District Attorney Richard Hinchcliff's request, Judge Martin set Beavers' bail at $2.9 million, which adheres to the standard bail schedule.
“Any questions?” Judge Martin asked Beavers after going over all of his counts and bail.
“No sir,” said Beavers, sitting in the front row of the jury box, wearing a black and white jail jumpsuit, his head newly shaved.
Orlando Esquivel, Angel Esquivel and Alicea each are facing one count of conspiracy. They are alleged to have had knowledge of the murder and to have harbored, concealed or aided Beavers. Police said the three are believed to have helped hide evidence.
While standard bail for conspiracy is $15,000, due to the seriousness of being accessories to a first-degree murder and two attempted murders, Hinchcliff asked that bail for the Esquivels and Alicea be set at $250,000.
Martin approved the request and granted leave for further bail review at a future time.
“This is just not a mere aiding and abetting. It's aiding and abetting some very, very serious crimes,” Martin said.
Martin appointed attorneys for all four suspects: Doug Rhoades will represent Beavers and Barry Melton will be counsel for Orlando Esquivel, while Komnith Moth will take Alicea's case and Mitchell Hauptman will represent Angel Esquivel.
All four suspects are next to appear in court at 8:15 a.m. Tuesday, Sept. 17, in Judge Andrew Blum's Department 3 courtroom.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. . Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.