
MIDDLETOWN, Calif. – The White Cap Murders that took place in Middletown, in 1890 were considered the most heinous crimes in Lake County history.
In her book, “The California White Cap Murders,” Helen Rocca Goss goes into great detail about the crimes.
White Caps were “groups of lawless bands,” according to Goss.
They formed in south Indiana, and then spread to nearby states, then finally in the West.
Goss’ father was Andrew Rocca, who was then superintendent of the Great Western Quicksilver Mine, located about three miles from the scene of the crimes.
According to Goss, he was “called to serve as a member of the coroner’s jury to examine the cause of Mrs. Riche’s death.”
But I am getting ahead of myself.
It was a typical, chilly fall Lake County evening on Oct. 10. The skies were clear and full of twinkling stars. The town was bustling with activity this particular evening, as there was a major gala social event taking place – the candidate’s ball.
About three miles south of Middletown at a saloon called “Campers’ Retreat” all was quiet.
Normally, the local quicksilver miners from the nearby mines – such as The Bradford, Mirabel, Great Western, Oat Hill or others – overflowed the establishment, drinking, playing cards and noisily debating local politics.
It was 9 p.m., and only the owner, J.W. Riche, his wife Helen Matilda Riche and Fred Bennett, the bartender, were present.
It's important to note that the name, “Riche” was spelled in varying forms by different newspapers of the day. It was spelled Ritch, Ritchie and so on, but during preliminary investigations in Middletown he spelled it, “Riche.”
While Mrs. Riche and Mr. Bennett played cards, Mr. Riche sat and observed the friendly game.
Suddenly the door was thrown open and a masked man entered the room. Soon to follow were about a half a dozen more men with shotguns, rifles and other firearms drawn.
Mr. Riche thought he recognized one of the men as a miner who worked the Bradford Mine and breathed a sigh of relief, assuming it was an early Halloween trick. When a bullet nearly grazed his head, he fully understood the serious intent of the intruders.
Mrs. Riche decided to take matters into her own hands, and promptly ripped the white cap off one of the intruders.
It seems that everything broke loose at once then, and Mr. Riche tried in vain to pull his wife to safety and shield her with his body.
Just then, a cacophony arose and a myriad of gunshots filled the room. Mrs. Riche had been wounded by a shot in her side.
Although wounded, she managed to pick up her husband’s Winchester 44 in hopes of retaliating, but her plan did not succeed.
Riche testified later that, “one man grabbed the rifle from her hand and threw it behind him.”
Then, the White Caps decided to leave the establishment. Most backed their way out, guns brazenly aimed at them, but Bennett threw the last one out.
Not to be trifled with, the White Caps opened up with a new volley of fire.
Shaken, Riche carried his wife to the bedroom and asked Bennett to go for the doctor.
While nervously awaiting the doctor’s arrival, Riche heard more footsteps on his porch.
He tore open the door and aimed his revolvers out into the dark, yelling at whoever was there that he was now quite prepared for them. It became eerily quiet.
As the festivities of the ball were beginning in Middletown, the reverie was interrupted by Bennett, who came galloping in on his horse, yelling for help.
Dr. Hartley immediately left the party, and was trailed by Constable J.W. Ransdell, Sheriff Moore, District Attorney Sayre and many others who were eager to get to the bottom of this crime.
One man, who was found by some neighbors on the Riche’s porch, could give no answers; he was dead.
It seems that it was the body of one McGuyre, who, as Dr. Hartley stated, wore “a most fiendish looking disguise.”
He was wearing an outfit with red sleeves. Burlap sacks made up the rest of his makeshift shirt and pants. White flour-sack masks were found near the house, along with a bucket of tar.
Dr. Hartley learned that Mrs. Riche had sustained five gunshot wounds. She only lived four days after the incident.
Much of the town attended services at the Middletown Methodist church, and then formed a procession to the cemetery.
The story of the murders was covered by many newspapers, including the Middletown “Independent,” the “Calistogian,” the Lakeport “Democrat” and the San Francisco “Examiner.”
Ten men were eventually arrested. Some, like Charles Osgood, chief engineer at the Bradford Mine, Charles Evans, a Bradford Mine employee, and Henry Arkarro stated that they did not intend to injure the Riches.
Instead, they had planned to attack Bennett. They wanted to “flog him well, give him a coat of tar and feathers, and then escort him to the border of the county and order him never to set foot within it again.”
Three men were turned in to the Lakeport jail without bail, accused of murder: B.F. Staley, A.E. Bichard and J. Archer, all employees of the Bradford Mine.
Before the legal proceedings were ever completed, Mr. Riche died of “apoplexy of the brain.”
It was believed that all of the sadness and stresses of the events, along with a bullet wound to his side having never healed properly, no doubt led to his early demise.
Andrew Rocca was appointed executor of his will and vowed to “champion the Riche’s cause” and “find and prosecute the perpetrators of the crime.”
It turns out that the murderers, according to historian Henry Mauldin, “were not outlaws or desperados, but just plain ordinary people, most of them were well known in Middletown or at the neighboring mines.”
At the conclusion of the trial there were no death sentences given. They spent time in San Quentin Prison, with the longest term given to a man named Blackburn, who was released on Sept. 26, 1897.
Kathleen Scavone, M.A., is an educator, potter, writer and author of “Anderson Marsh State Historic Park: A Walking History, Prehistory, Flora, and Fauna Tour of a California State Park” and “Native Americans of Lake County.” She also writes for NASA and JPL as one of their “Solar System Ambassadors.” She was selected “Lake County Teacher of the Year, 1998-99” by the Lake County Office of Education, and chosen as one of 10 state finalists the same year by the California Department of Education.
