![Emilio Vega Mendoza, 44, of Clearlake, Calif., was convicted on Tuesday, July 28, 2015, of severely abusing a German Shepherd puppy. He's shown here in his mug shot when he was arrested on Saturday, April 26, 2015. The injuries on his face came from the abused dog, although on the stand during his trial he denied the dog injured him. Lake County Jail photo. 042615vegamendozamug](/images/042615vegamendozamug.jpg)
LAKEPORT, Calif. – A Clearlake man has been convicted of three felony charges in connection to his torturing of a German Shepherd puppy – including punching it while he hung it from a tree.
Emilio Vega Mendoza, 44, was found guilty of intentionally and maliciously torturing Remy – who was not quite a year old at the time of the April incident – along with making criminal threats to a witness and attempting to make threats to a Clearlake Police officer, according to Deputy District Attorney Susan Krones.
Mendoza was found not guilty of a fourth charge of making threats to deter the officer from performing his duties, Krones said.
Krones said Vega Mendoza waived a jury trial and instead had a bench trial before Judge Michael Lunas on July 23, with the verdict coming down on Tuesday.
Vega Mendoza's defense attorney, Mark Cabaniss of Lakeport, did not respond to requests from Lake County News for comment on the case.
Clearlake Police Officer Michael Dietrick arrested Vega Mendoza on the morning of April 26 at a residence on Saroni Parkway after getting reports of him torturing the dog, and threatening a woman and her child, according to the case records.
The dog was being punched like a punching bag while being hung from a tree, said Clearlake Police Lt. Tim Celli.
Krones said Vega Mendoza was living in a shed on the property where the beating took place. On the morning of the incident, a woman who lived in the house on the property came out to find him hanging Remy from a rope that was thrown over a tree branch, hitting the pup, lowering him, and then repeating the same abusive treatment numerous times.
Witnesses said Vega Mendoza was drunk, and when the woman confronted him and told him to stop harming the dog, he told her to mind her own business. She told him she would call the police if he didn't stop, and he then threatened to go into the house, take the woman's 1-month-old daughter and harm her, Krones said.
During the time when Remy was being hung from the tree and beaten, he began to thrash around and snapped at Vega Mendoza, biting him in the face, Krones said. In his booking sheet, Vega Mendoza has facial injuries as a result.
Celli said that when officers arrived at the scene, Remy – who is very friendly – ran to them and hid behind them.
He then got into the police car, and – considering that he looks like a police dog – was right at home, riding with his head out the window, Celli said.
Krones said a rope was found over a tree branch at the scene. Remy didn't have neck injuries, but he did appear to have a preexisting hip injury, exhibiting a noticeable limp.
Vega Mendoza was arrested and taken to the hospital for his facial injuries before he was booked into the Lake County Jail. “He’s been in custody ever since,” said Krones.
Part of the reason for Vega Mendoza remaining in jail is a hold placed on him by the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE.
Krones said Vega Mendoza claimed to have been in the United States for many years. He's listed as a carpenter on his booking sheet, and she said he has been working for his cousin.
She added that she is not sure how the immigration hold will play into the case. “They have not been putting ICE holds on everybody,” she added, noting that used to be a much more common practice.
![Remy, a German Shepherd, was about 1 year old at the time he was hung and beaten by his owner, 44-year-old Emilio Vega Mendoza of Clearlake, Calif. Mendoza was arrested in the case on Saturday, April 26, 2015. Courtesy photo. remygermanshepherd2](/images/remygermanshepherd2.jpg)
Unconvincing testimony
During his trial, Vega Mendoza took the stand, denying all of the allegations, Krones said.
“He said he was just playing with the dog,” Krones said.
Vega Mendoza claimed that he had his jacket around his arm and he was teaching Remy to be an attack dog. He also stated that witnesses must have mistook the dog's jumping around for being hoisted up by the rope.
“He said he was teaching the dog a lesson, but what lesson is that?” Krones asked.
He also testified that he was not drunk and that the dog didn't bite him in the face, but that he had been scratched on a fence the day before, Krones said.
She said Vega Mendoza's testimony didn't make sense. “The judge did not think his testimony was credible.”
Vega Mendoza is due to be sentenced Sept. 9, Krones said.
He's facing a maximum of three years in state prison – not the county jail – due to the severity of the crimes for which he was convicted, with both of the threat charges being strikes. Due to the ICE hold, he's also not eligible for probation, Krones added.
Because the charges came from the same incident, Vega Mendoza is likely to get sentences that run concurrently, Krones said.
She said Vega Mendoza has no previous animal cruelty cases or felonies, but he has had priors going back to 1997, the most serious of which was a misdemeanor criminal threat case in 2012 that occurred outside of Lake County and resulted in him being placed on probation.
The felony strike convictions in the dog abuse case may result in Vega Mendoza being deported. Krones said it is likely he will serve prison time first, although it's ultimately up to immigration authorities.
There are several other animal cruelty cases involving dogs working their way through the local courts now, said Krones.
She's also handling the case against Clearlake resident Michael Truscott, who was arrested in May after police said he threw a 9-month-old puppy to the ground and broke her jaw.
A friend of Truscott's submitted to Lake County News a voice recording of him claiming that he accidentally injured the dog.
As for Remy, after Vega Mendoza was arrested, Remy was taken to the SPCA of Clear Lake, which has held an animal control contract with the city of Clearlake since October 2013.
SPCA Executive Director Mary Jane Montana called news of the verdict “awesome.”
She said Remy is a sweet dog who this spring was adopted out to a new home, details about which she can't disclose. She added that he'll never have to worry about Vega Mendoza abusing him again.
Montana said Remy had severe dysplasia in the injured leg and apparently in another as well, which was disclosed to the adopter.
Both she and Krones said the dog is awaiting hip replacement surgery.
“I'm glad the dog’s in a good home and hopefully he’ll get the surgery he needs,” Krones said.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. . Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.