- Elizabeth Larson
- Posted On
Judge sentences Upper Lake man to state prison for killing mother of his children
Judge J. David Markham sentenced Willy Tujays Timmons, 41, to 16 years to life in state prison for the June 2017 killing of Vanessa Yvette Niko.
In November, a jury found Timmons guilty of second-degree murder for Niko’s killing. They also convicted him of torture, inflicting injury resulting in a traumatic condition and aggravated mayhem, and special allegations of use of a deadly weapon and personally inflicting bodily injury.
Timmons had a history of domestic violence before the murder, which occurred on June 30, 2017.
Niko, a member of the Habematolel Pomo tribe, has become Lake County’s prime example of a victim of the epidemic of missing and murdered Indigenous women, also known as MMIW, which often is rooted in domestic violence.
She had six children, three of them with Timmons. At the time of the murder, she and Timmons were reportedly staying away from each other.
However, on June 30, 2017, family members said Timmons picked Niko up, along with her youngest child.
He drove her to his grandmother’s residence on Bridge Arbor Road in Upper Lake, where he was living with his grandmother and father, according to Senior Deputy District Attorney Rachel Abelson.
It was there that a deputy would respond to a report of an assault. Timmons, high on methamphetamine and in a jealous rage, struck Niko on the head with a rock as she held her little daughter in her arms. Niko died shortly after the deputy’s arrival.
Timmons was arrested on the day of the murder and has remained in custody since then, with numerous delays before the case finally went to trial in the fall. He also had pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity at one point during the proceedings.
While that insanity defense did not stand, defense attorney Tom Feimer stated during the Tuesday sentencing that a doctor who had testified at trial found Timmons to have schizophrenia, and that Timmons gave testimony consistent with that.
However, Abelson replied that Timmons’ “vicious acts” were not so much an issue of mental health as of him being under the influence of methamphetamine.
‘I just want to know why’
Throughout the proceedings, Niko’s cousin Ida Morrison has been present to bear witness on behalf of her family.
It was Morrison who was a driving force in the creation of a mural in downtown Upper Lake, dedicated last year, that portrays Niko.
Over the past four years, she had often been accompanied by Niko’s mother, Coveda Miller. Attending the hearings and trial was an effort that Morrison said on Tuesday had not been easy.
Miller was able to see the conviction in November, but she died in January.
Morrison was once again present on Tuesday morning, one of three family members who gave emotional statements about the impact of Niko’s killing on their lives. Abelson said a beautiful portrait of Miller was shown during the sentencing.
In her statement, Morrison recounted both her joy at the beginning of her younger cousin’s life — recalling her as a beautiful baby — as well as the horrifying ending.
“He took my baby girl’s life in front of her baby girl,” she said, adding that her nephews will forever be changed by the killing. “You have taught them to hate.”
She said Timmons doesn’t have to sit and watch the children become sad over everyday events. “What they want is for their mom Vanessa to be with them.”
Morrison said Timmons should have let Niko go, explaining she was trying to get a better life for herself and her children, and that she had been pursuing education. “You just kept dragging her back down.”
Niko’s oldest daughter, Leannlynn Faber, also gave a victim impact statement, during which she explained having to raise her siblings and reflecting on how her mother was missing out on knowing her grandchildren.
“You have torn my life apart,” Faber told Timmons.
“The reason I want to speak today is because my mother loved you,” she said. “And you did something horrible to her. I just want to know why. And how could you do that in front of my siblings?”
Faber said Timmons had spread lies about her mother. “My mom loved you with everything she had in her and I don’t know why you took a good person away from us,” she said, calling her mother “a beautiful soul.”
“I hope you’re tortured everyday knowing what you did to my mom,” she said. “You have to live with that everyday for the rest of your life.”
Retired teacher speaks in Timmons’ defense
The defense then called retired teacher Kent Wooldridge to the stand, a move that appeared to be meant to help Timmons but resulted in an admonishment from the judge and statements which were not factually correct, including his claims that Timmons was an orphan.
Wooldridge had no part in the trial and was not a witness to anything involving it, Abelson told Lake County News. At one point in the trial he was observed attempting to talk to the jurors and possibly interfere but Abelson said there were no jurors — when questioned generically — that were impacted by his conduct.
Wooldridge said he had known Timmons since he was in junior high school and had been a teacher in the school district.
At the urging of other staff, he had tried to work with Timmons on his truancy issues. Wooldridge, who said he’d had a foster home at that time, said Timmons hadn’t had a fixed address and was living with a cousin.
Wooldridge suggested that, had he been able to get Timmons back in school, they wouldn’t be sitting there today.
He said Timmons had come to his foster home to hang out with another young man who later was murdered by his girlfriend in another jurisdiction.
Regarding that case, Wooldridge said, “There is a giant sized hole in my heart that you could drive a truck through,” he said, adding that Timmons was at that funeral.
“There is plenty of misery to go around here,” he said.
“Growing up in Lake County is tough for kids in the best of circumstances,” Wooldridge said, adding that foster children have a particular challenge.
Feimer asked if Timmons had any adult family figures growing up. Wooldridge said no. While they’d heard at trial about aunts and cousins who did the best they could when he was little, but “there was no paper” that went along with him.
“When he needed help, a lot of times it wasn’t there. Had it been there, it would have been a nice thing. So he was on his own a lot,” said Wooldridge.
Feimer asked about Timmons’ positive qualities. Wooldridge replied, “There was nothing negative about him in sobriety. In sobriety, he was a fine guy.”
Wooldridge also claimed that Timmons has been kept away from other inmates in solitary confinement for almost three years due to death threats he has received.
As the questioning drew to a close, Judge Markham began to admonish Wooldridge for not answering Feimer’s questions and for making unrelated comments.
Markham told Wooldridge that he needed to respond to the questions, that it wasn’t the opportunity for a speech.
When Wooldridge again failed to respond as directed, Markham had the clerk read a question back and said he needed to give a yes or no answer.
When Wooldridge gave a “yes” response and then added in a statement about Timmons being a good guy, Markham lost patience.
“You need to really pay attention to me,” said Markham, telling Wooldridge that he would cut off his testimony. Wooldridge then stepped down from the witness stand.
‘I took her out of this world’
After Wooldridge left the stand, Feimer announced to the court that Timmons wished to apologize.
Wearing a striped orange and white Lake County Jail jumpsuit and accompanied by a deputy, Timmons made his way to the witness stand.
Sitting before the court, Timmons wept as he told Niko’s family he was sorry to everybody for her killing.
“There’s nothing that I could say that would make any difference. I took her out of this world,” he said.
He acknowledged that the impact of her death harmed others, adding that he believed her mother died of a broken heart.
“My babies have got no mom or dad now,” Timmons said.
“I feel like I dwell in hell a lot now, and I deserve it,” he said before stepping down after just a few minutes on the stand.
Judge passes sentence
Feimer had asked for Markham to strike one of the enhancements, which would have reduced the sentence by a year.
Markham declined to do so, and went forward with giving the sentence, noting Timmons’ criminal record and history of domestic violence — he was on probation for two such cases at the time of the murder — as well as the cruelty and callousness of the crime, which was committed in front of Niko’s child.
Markham pointed out that Timmons had acknowledged wrongdoing — but not until after a jury convicted him.
He went through the sentences for each of the charges, explaining that the final sentence was 16 years to life, with Timmons eligible for parole after 16 years.
However, Markham said that process would require parole hearings and the input of victims, adding he didn’t think any reasonable person would find Timmons should be released after 16 years.
Markham went on to say that he was not impressed by Wooldridge. To come into the court and tell the victims that he also had suffered, “The court frankly finds it offensive,” Markham said.
He added that neither he nor Wooldridge knew what Niko’s family had gone through.
It was noted during the sentencing that Timmons would receive credit — of more than five years on some of the counts — for time served toward that overall sentence, but that the overall calculation ultimately would be up to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
If Timmons ever were to be released, Markham said he would face lifetime parole, unless he filed an appeal.
Markham then ordered Timmons to be remanded and delivered to state corrections to start serving his prison sentence.
Abelson said the family was strong throughout the painful process and delays. She said she was pleased the family got some justice for Niko.
“I just wish her mother was here to finally see it,” Abelson said.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.