LAKEPORT, Calif. – The jury in the murder trial of a former Maine resident heard from one of the man’s oldest friends about the circumstances that led to the murders of a Maine couple in early 2010.
Thirty-year-old Elijah Bae McKay was on the witness stand for the entire day Friday in the trial of his childhood friend, Robby Alan Beasley.
The 32-year-old Beasley is on trial for the January 2010 murders of Frank and Yvette Maddox of Augusta, Maine.
Beasley is charged with two counts of murder, and special allegations of committing multiple murders in the first or second degree, committing the offenses with the intent to inflict great bodily injury on the victims and using a 9 millimeter firearm to shoot the Maddoxes multiple times along the side of Morgan Valley Road near Lower Lake before dragging their bodies down an embankment.
McKay, Beasley and the Maddoxes all were involved in the lucrative marijuana industry, with the motivation to kill them being that Beasley allegedly believed that the Maddoxes had stolen marijuana from him.
Growing and trafficking marijuana would be a topic of much of McKay’s Friday testimony.
McKay had been on the stand briefly on the first day of testimony on Wednesday. At that time he made a statement during what Judge Andrew Blum said on Friday was a “long-winded narrative” that could have caused prejudice. Specifically, McKay had recalled that Beasley had “threatened to kill people” years ago in high school in Maine.
Defense attorney Stephen Carter filed a mistrial motion over the comment, which Blum again admonished the jury on Friday to disregard. Blum has not yet made a ruling on the mistrial motion.
Under questioning by Senior Deputy District Attorney Art Grothe, McKay recounted a conversation on the porch of his Lower Lake home on the morning of Jan. 20, 2010, two days before Beasley is alleged to have killed the Maddoxes.
Beasley brought up the idea of killing the couple, saying he already had dug holes for their bodies. He suggested pulling out their teeth to prevent them from being identified. McKay testified that he thought that would have been “ridiculous” and that it would be easier to chop off their heads, but that their hands also would need to be chopped off to prevent their fingerprints from being used to identify them.
McKay said he told Beasley that killing the couple was a bad idea due to all of the trouble he would get into. He also suggested that if Beasley killed the Maddoxes, he would never get back the money from the marijuana they allegedly stole from his Clearlake apartment.
McKay testified to telling Beasley that he should instead scare them by shooting off some rounds at their feet and interrogating them, and telling them to go back to Maine and work off the money. “He agreed to do that rather than shoot them,” McKay said.
Beasley planned to use the pretense that his grandmother had died to get the Maddoxes to agree to giving him a ride to the airport. McKay recalled Beasley making himself tear up so he could convince them he was grieving. “I was very surprised that he could make himself cry.”
Two days later, McKay was at his brother’s birthday party in Clearlake in the late afternoon. Beasley called him and said the Maddoxes had agreed to give him a ride to the airport, and he planned to try to scare them. However, he wanted McKay to be ready to come and pick him up, as he didn’t believe he would be able to be in the vehicle with them after threatening them.
Within a few hours, Beasley texted McKay saying he was ready to be picked up. “Change of plans, meet me at the gate,” was what McKay recalled the text said.
When McKay found Beasley with the Maddoxes’ pickup on the side of the road, not far from McKay’s home, an “extremely distressed” Beasley told him, “It didn’t work out as planned.”
McKay asked where the Maddoxes were. Beasley said he had shot them. McKay then asked if he had at least buried them. “He said no, that there were cars driving by and he got scared,” McKay testified.
When McKay told Beasley he was going to drive him back to where the bodies were so he could bury them, Beasley refused and a frustrated McKay gave up trying to convince him. Instead, he took Beasley back to his house.
“I was basically trying to make a bad situation better,” McKay said.
McKay said he stripped Beasley naked, burned all of his clothes, backpack and both of their cell phones on his back lawn. He gave Beasley some clothes, including a leather jacket. The next morning, they moved the couples’ pickup down to the Jerusalem Grade area near Middletown.
Recounting details of roadside confrontation
McKay said Beasley told him that as he was riding with the Maddoxes down Morgan Valley Road he asked them to pull over in a turnout so he could urinate. Frank Maddox got out with him, and while they were out of the pickup Beasley alleged pulled out a 9 millimeter pistol McKay had loaned him.
Beasley then pulled Yvette Maddox from the pickup and began to interrogate them about stealing his marijuana, but neither would admit to it, despite him firing some rounds into the ground at their feet, said McKay.
After they still wouldn’t talk, Beasley shot Frank Maddox in the leg and Yvette Maddox fainted or, as McKay recalled Beasley describing it, “played possum.”
Frank Maddox reportedly told Beasley, “You shot me. You better kill me or I’ll kill you,” McKay testified.
He said Beasley shot Frank Maddox in the head before also shooting Yvette Maddox in the head. Beasley then drug both down the hill and, in the process of doing so, realized both were still alive. So he shot each of them in the head again.
When Beasley saw vehicles driving by, he told McKay that he panicked and left, driving the pickup to a nearby gate. McKay would later tell Beasley that he didn’t appreciate being put at risk by having Beasley kill the couple and dump their bodies near his driveway.
Beasley offered McKay $20,000 to bury the couple, but McKay told him there was “no way in hell” he would put his footprints out there.
McKay also testified that Beasley had offered him $20,000 to kill the Maddoxes during the conversation on his porch two days before the murders.
“I told him no,” McKay said. “If he wanted them dead he'd have to do it himself.”
When the men went to get rid of the Maddoxes’ pickup the day after the murders, McKay said Beasley was having second thoughts because they didn’t admit their guilt.
He said Beasley also had raised suspicions about another couple having stolen the marijuana, suggesting maybe he should kill them, testimony that Carter wanted to keep out. The judge will hear motions on that evidence next week.
As for the 9 millimeter handgun that Beasley borrowed from McKay and is alleged to have used in the murders, he told McKay, “Nobody’s ever going to find it,” McKay said on the stand.
Under Carter’s cross-examination, McKay explained that he had been born in Santa Rosa, and when he was 1 year old his family moved to Maine, where he lived until he was 22 years old.
McKay lived in Gardiner, seven miles outside of Augusta, where he and Beasley grew up together.
Later, he moved back to California, working in the Bay Area, and eventually coming north, spending several years growing marijuana in Mendocino County before coming over to grow in Lake County. He would invite Beasley to come out and work for him.
He said he met the Maddoxes in the fall of 2009 before heading to New York for a fishing trip. Beasley had done well for himself in the previous year and wanted to bring the Maddoxes, who were friends, out so he could help them.
Beasley helped take care of McKay’s growing operation when he was gone on the fishing trip, getting a pound of marijuana, worth about $2,500, in return. The only time McKay said he had contact with Beasley during the trip was when Beasley called to tell him he had chopped the tip off of his finger.
Blum ordered the jury to return at 11 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 14, when testimony will continue.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. . Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.