- Elizabeth Larson
Santa Rosa man who died in jail had been offered plea deal in burglary, evasion case
LAKEPORT, Calif. – A Santa Rosa man found dead in his jail cell last week was potentially facing several years in prison for a January burglary and vehicle pursuit, but not for ramming his pickup into a Lakeport Police officer's vehicle, an action which resulted in him being shot by a sheriff's deputy.
James Ellis Smith, 37, was identified by sheriff’s Lt. Steve Brooks as the inmate who died last Saturday, May 10, at the Lake County Jail.
Officials said a correctional officer found Smith just after 9 a.m. that day during a routine cell check.
Jail staff and Lakeport Fire personnel worked for about half an hour to revive Smith before ceasing cardiopulmonary resuscitation at about 9 a.m., according to Brooks’ original report.
Foul play is not suspected. Brooks said an official statement on the cause of death is pending completion of an autopsy.
District Attorney Don Anderson’s office is conducting investigations into both Smith's death and the officer-involved shooting in which he was injured prior to his January arrest.
Smith was shot early on the morning of Jan. 3 following a burglary attempt at Hillside Honda that led to a high speed chase with a Lakeport Police officer and a sheriff's deputy.
It was shortly after 4 a.m. Jan. 3 that a Lakeport Police officer – who Anderson said was Officer Joe Eastham – encountered Smith as he was attempting to break into the business on S. Main Street.
Smith would flee the scene in a pickup, reaching speeds of 100 miles per hour, according to officials.
Eastham – joined by sheriff’s Deputy Jay Vanoven – pursued Smith out of the city and to the area of Riggs Road, where Smith went off the pavement, Anderson said.
Smith put the pickup into reverse and backed up at high speed into Eastham's patrol vehicle. Eastham then got out of the vehicle, at which point Smith was preparing to back up the vehicle again, according to the investigation.
At that point, Vanoven shot six times at Smith, hitting him in the elbow and body, and grazing him in the head, according to Anderson.
Anderson said his investigation into the officer-involved shooting has concluded that Vanoven was justified in his actions. He expects to finalize and issue his report on that investigation in the near future.
Smith was transported to an out-of-county trauma center before being taken into custody and booked into the Lake County Jail on Jan. 10, with bail set at $150,000.
Since then he had made court appearances, and a preliminary hearing was set in his case for June 4, with Deputy District Attorney Jon DeChaine handling the prosecution, Anderson said.
On May 8, the District Attorney's Office delivered an open plea deal to Smith's Santa Rosa attorney, according to Anderson.
Anderson said that the plea would have required Smith – who had no significant criminal history, just minor cases in Sonoma County – to plead to burglary and felony evasion, with a maximum prison sentence expected to be three years, eight months.
Not charged in the case against Smith was assault on Officer Eastham with the pickup. “The assault on the officer was going to be extremely difficult to prove,” said Anderson.
Whether Smith accepted the plea agreement or not was not reported to the District Attorney's Office, Anderson said.
Email Elizabeth Larson at